| N° | § N° | U/AI | CR | Date | Comment | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5. | AI | No | add date | All requested positions specify 'RS cold' (cold finished), and ASTM B167 covers seamless, cold worked tubes, fulfilling the requirement for seamless cold worked material. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/02 - Specifications-Digest-collection/02-0... | Open |
| 2 | 5. | AI | No | add date | Is fulfilled because ASTM B167 for UNS N06690 (DMV 690) requires supply in the annealed and de-scaled condition, and all referenced sources confirm compliance for the supplied tubes in accordance with the material specification. --- Sources: - DM... | Open |
| 3 | 5. | AI | No | add date | 100% of the product is subject to either a Nondestructive Electric Test (Eddy Current) or Hydrostatic test in accordance with ASTM B167 and B829 code requirements, fulfilling the requirement for hydrostatic test and NDE as per code requirements. --- ... | Open |
| 4 | 5. | AI | No | add date | No evidence that DMV 690 (UNS N06690) meets the specified grain size of 2 to 5 (target 3 to 4) per ASTM E112; requirement not fulfilled by available information. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/12-03-03 - Grain Size Examination in DMV-I.doc - DMV_ST... | Open |
| 5 | 5. | AI | No | add date | Marking methods include metal stamping, which is prohibited; requirement not fulfilled. --- Source: DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/13 - Marking/13-02 - Standard marking feasibility/13-02-01 - Standard marking feasibility - Montbard plant/13-02-01 - Standard mark... | Open |
| 6 | 5. | AI | No | add date | Is fulfilled because all tubes are supplied with deburred ends, meeting the requirement to remove burrs and sharp edges. --- Sources: - Digest ASTM B 167-11 (reapproved 2016) | Open |
| 7 | 5. | AI | No | add date | 100% qualitative anti-mixing PMI checks are performed on all standard production raw materials using appropriate instruments, fulfilling the requirement for PMI on all raw materials. --- Source: DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/12 - Special Testing/12-02 - Non dest... | Open |
| 8 | 5. | AI | No | add date | No referenced documents require or verify absence of a continuous network of grain boundary carbides; no microstructural examination or controls are specified for this feature in the evaluated sources. --- Sources: - Digest ASTM B 167-11 (reapproved ... | Open |
| 9 | 5. | AI | No | add date | Inside diameter 34.2 +/- 0.1mm is fulfilled, but no evidence confirms straightness 0.5mm is met or feasible; standard only covers up to 0.8mm or requires special agreement for tighter tolerance, which is not confirmed here. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDAR... | Open |
| 10 | 5. | AI | No | add date | No referenced standard or document specifies or confirms a straightness tolerance of 0.5mm; only general requirements for reasonable straightness are stated, and 0.5mm is not standard or demonstrated for DMV 690 products or ASTM B167 tubes. Sources: ... | Open |
| 11 | 5. | AI | No | add date | Is fulfilled because Item 6 specifies inside diameter 34.2 +/- 0.1mm, matching the requirement exactly. --- Sources: DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/02-03-02 - Digest ASTM B 167-18.doc, Angie | Open |
| 12 | 5. | AI | No | add date | No evidence that 0.7mm straightness is standard or feasible for Item No.7; ASTM B167 and internal specifications do not specify or confirm this tolerance for Remscheid cold finished tubes or DMV 690 grade. Requested straightness is not covered by ref... | Open |
| 13 | 5. | AI | No | add date | O.D. tolerance of +/- 0.25mm is specified for all positions; thickness is per CODE requirements as standard; length tolerance is covered by DMV standard practices and specification tolerances are acceptable without cost impact. --- Sources: DMV_STAN... | Open |
| 14 | 5. | AI | No | add date | O.D. tolerance of +/- 0.25mm is explicitly listed for all positions and is within or equal to ASTM B167 standard tolerances; customer-specified tolerance is applied and accepted by the standard and database records. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_B... | Open |
| 15 | 5. | AI | No | add date | Is fulfilled because ASTM B167 specifies wall thickness requirements and tolerances, and all referenced digests and tables confirm that DMV 690 (UNS N06690) tubes are supplied with thicknesses and tolerances per ASTM B167 and ASTM B829 Table 2, cover... | Open |
| 16 | 5. | AI | No | add date | No evidence that +/- 1mm length tolerance is standard or achievable; referenced standards and feasibility documents indicate wider tolerances or do not confirm this tolerance is met. All inquiry positions specify '+/- 0.25mm' or do not mention +/- 1m... | Open |
| 17 | 5. | AI | No | add date | PWHT at 900°C (+14/-14°C) for 4.0 (+1.0/-0) hours for mechanical test specimens is not provided, required, or delegated for cold finished products at Montbard; no relevant standard or process documentation confirms fulfillment for Items 6 and 7. --- ... | Open |
| 18 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | Not fulfilled because only ASTM B167 UNS N06690 (DMV 690) is available, while the requirement is for ASTM B167 UNS N06600 (Alloy 600); the grades have different chemical compositions and properties, and no evidence of N06600 availability or delegatio... | Open |
| 19 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | Requirement is for ASTM B167 N06600, but only ASTM B167 N06690 (DMV 690) is offered; N06690 is not equivalent to N06600 and does not fulfill the requirement for grade or minimum quantity where applicable. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/02-03-02 - ... | Open |
| 20 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | Not fulfilled because only DMV 690 (UNS N06690) is available and feasible; ASTM B167 N06600 (UNS N06600) is not offered or supported for the requested dimensions and grade, and the grades are not equivalent or substitutable per ASTM B167 requirements... | Open |
| 21 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | ASTM B167 N06600 (Alloy 600) is required, but only DMV 690 (UNS N06690, Alloy 690) is available; N06600 is not offered or feasible in the provided data or tables, so the requirement is not fulfilled. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/02 - Specificatio... | Open |
| 22 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | Requirement is for ASTM B167 N06600, but only ASTM B167 N06690 (DMV 690) is available; N06600 is not offered or listed in the provided data, and N06690 is not a substitute for N06600 due to different chemical composition and properties. --- Sources: ... | Open |
| 23 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | Requirement is for ASTM B167 N06600 tube, but only ASTM B167 N06690 (DMV 690) is available; N06600 is not offered or confirmed for the requested dimensions and specification, and the grades are not equivalent or interchangeable for this requirement. ... | Open |
| 24 | PIPE LIST | AI | No | add date | Only DMV 690 (UNS N06690) is available and offered; ASTM B167 N06600 (UNS N06600) is not available or offered, and the material grade does not match the requirement for N06600 tube in any position or plant data. No evidence of N06600 compliance or de... | Open |
| 25 | Attachment-1 | AI | No | add date | Is fulfilled because DMV 690 (UNS N06690) is produced according to ASTM B167 with no indication of Iranian origin or non-compliance with export control laws; standard compliance and traceability are maintained. --- Sources: - Angie | Open |
| 26 | Attachment-1 | AI | No | add date | No information on EAR applicability, U.S. origin, U.S.-origin content, or use of U.S. technology or software is provided in the relevant documents or data sources. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/14-01 - General information.doc - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/1... | Open |
| 27 | Attachment-1 | AI | No | add date | DMV 690 cold finished production is not delegated to Houston (USA); all production is assigned to European plants, with no evidence of US production for the goods or services requested for this inquiry. ASTM B167 and UNS N06690 compliance is confirme... | Open |
| 28 | Attachment-1 | AI | No | add date | No information on U.S.-origin or controlled content percentage is provided in any relevant source; requirement cannot be validated as fulfilled. --- Sources: - DMV_STANDARD_BOOK/12-06-06 - Positive Material Identification (PMI) in Montbard.docx - DMV... | Open |
| 29 | Attachment-1 | AI | No | add date | No relevant documentation confirms goods/services are non-U.S.-made products from U.S.-origin technology or software; only technical standards and U.S.-based manufacturing or testing are described, without origin details or technology provenance. --... | Open |
| 30 | Attachment-1 | AI | No | add date | No evidence provided regarding use of U.S.-origin technology or software in production at non-U.S. plants; country of manufacture confirmed as non-U.S., but technology origin unverified. --- Sources: - Angie | Open |
